A Soul of Ash and Blood serves as both a retelling and companion to Jennifer L. Armentrout's popular From Blood and Ash, narrated from love interest Hawke's point of view. This book will primarily appeal to existing fans of the series who want deeper insight into Hawke's motivations and backstory, particularly his centuries-long wait for Poppy and his complex relationship with his destiny as the Dark One.

Armentrout excels at building sexual tension and delivering the steamy romance scenes her readers expect, while expanding the Atlantian mythology and political intrigue that drives the overarching plot. The pacing mirrors the original novel but benefits from Hawke's more experienced perspective, adding layers to scenes that felt straightforward in Poppy's narration.

His internal struggle between duty and desire creates genuine emotional stakes, and Armentrout does well showing how his centuries of trauma shaped his initially manipulative approach to their relationship.

However, this book faces the inherent challenge of any retelling - readers already know the major plot points and romantic beats. While Hawke's perspective adds depth, it doesn't fundamentally change the story's trajectory or reveal shocking new information. The writing style remains accessible but occasionally repetitive, particularly in romantic scenes that can feel formulaic.

New readers should absolutely start with From Blood and Ash, as this book assumes familiarity with the world-building, supporting characters like Kieran and Delano, and the broader conflict between Atlantians and the Ascended. The mythology dumps that worked in the original feel more intrusive here since they're filtered through a character who already knows these details. Fans who loved the original series will find plenty to enjoy in the expanded romantic content and Hawke's tortured hero perspective, but those who found the first book's pacing slow or romance overwhelming should skip this one. It amplifies both the strengths and weaknesses of Armentrout's style without offering enough new material to convert skeptics.