'Pucking Around' is Emily Rath's entry into the crowded hockey romance arena, following Colton Morrow, a goaltender struggling with anxiety and depression, and Tess Owens, a sports psychologist hired to help the Jacksonville Rays. What sets this apart from typical sports romance is Rath's genuine commitment to exploring mental health issues rather than using them as mere plot devices.

Colton's panic attacks and therapy sessions feel authentic, not romanticized, and Tess maintains professional boundaries in ways that feel realistic for someone in her field. The hockey details are solid—Rath clearly understands the sport and locker room dynamics—and the team chemistry extends beyond the main couple to create a believable ensemble cast.

The steam level is high but not gratuitous, with emotional intimacy building alongside physical attraction.

However, the pacing stumbles in the middle third, where repetitive internal monologues slow momentum. Some readers may find Colton's self-deprecating thoughts exhausting rather than endearing, and Tess occasionally veers into 'fixing' territory despite the author's attempts to avoid this trope. The dialogue sparkles during banter but can feel stilted during emotional revelations.

Secondary characters like teammate Jake and Colton's sister provide welcome comic relief, though their subplots feel underdeveloped. This book works best for readers who want their romance with substance—those seeking pure escapism might find the mental health focus heavier than expected. Hockey romance fans will appreciate the authentic sports elements, while readers interested in mental health representation will find thoughtful, if imperfect, portrayal. Skip this if you prefer lighter contemporary romance or dislike first-person dual POV. The explicit content and mature themes make it firmly adult territory. Despite its flaws, Rath delivers an emotionally satisfying romance that respects both its characters' struggles and their growth.