Pip Williams follows up her acclaimed 'The Dictionary of Lost Words' with another Oxford-set historical novel that explores the intersection of books, class, and women's agency. 'The Bookbinder' centers on Peggy Jones, who works at Oxford University Press bindery while her twin sister Maude studies at Somerville College—a stark reminder of how birth order and circumstance shape destinies.

The novel spans from 1914 to the 1920s, chronicling how WWI transforms both sisters and their community. Williams excels at depicting the physical craft of bookbinding with tactile detail that makes readers appreciate the artistry behind every bound volume. Peggy's relationship with books—as objects she creates rather than texts she reads—offers a fresh perspective on literary passion.

The author skillfully weaves real historical figures and events into the narrative, particularly around women's suffrage and the war's impact on Oxford.

However, the novel suffers from uneven pacing, with the middle section dragging as Williams attempts to cover too much historical ground. The romance subplot between Peggy and Gideon feels underdeveloped, lacking the emotional depth that drives the book's stronger elements. Some readers may find Peggy's character arc predictable, following familiar beats of working-class woman discovering her voice and worth.

The dialogue occasionally feels stilted, particularly in scenes meant to convey period authenticity. This book will appeal most to readers who enjoyed Williams' previous work, fans of historical fiction focused on women's experiences, and anyone interested in book arts and printing history. Those seeking fast-paced plots or complex mysteries should look elsewhere. Readers who prefer contemporary settings or dislike detailed historical exposition may find it slow. The novel works best for those who appreciate character-driven stories about resilience, sisterhood, and finding one's place in a changing world. While not groundbreaking, 'The Bookbinder' offers a solid, immersive reading experience that honors both the craft of bookmaking and the women who practiced it.